Coaches burn out, too, and I've seen it happen. You're juggling recruiting, parents, your job and your own son, often for little or no pay.
“You're the coach, the recruiter, the party planner, the fundraiser and the scheduler. You do it all, and you probably shouldn't.”
Put your team's core values on one page, print it out and hand it to every family before the season starts. If you don't know what makes your team different, your players and parents won't either.
“Feel free to steal from ours so you can create your own!”
When a pitcher told me his arm was sore, he didn't pitch, and there was no debate. The bigger job for a coach is not creating sore arms in the first place.
“Yes, there's a difference between soreness and an injury, but the difference isn't always clear.”
If you routinely run a play that's outside the standard approach, I think it's your duty to track what happens. Otherwise, you're calling it out of habit without knowing whether it works.
“If you're going to bunt, steal or pull the infield in, you should know whether it's actually working.”
Diving into first base is almost never faster than running through the bag. It only makes sense when the throw pulls the first baseman off the base and a swipe tag is coming.
“Tell him you appreciate the effort, but the decision to dive was wrong.”
If the first baseman held the runner on and the pitcher threw from the stretch, I score it a stolen base. The defense wasn't indifferent just because the catcher didn't throw.
“Why would you rob a runner of a stolen base simply because he got a huge jump?”
With no outs and a close play coming at the plate, I'm holding the runner at third. He's very likely going to score anyway.
“Hey, there's no one out. Don't take any big risks on a wild pitch.”
A runner on second is already in scoring position. With no outs, he can score on a hit, or on a ground ball followed by a sacrifice fly.
“If you think the play at third with no outs is going to be close, hold up that stop sign.”
With two outs, a runner on second and a runner on third are both likely to score on a hit. Taking a big risk to get to third won't improve your odds very much.
“The number of outs matters. With two outs, you're only going to score on a hit anyway.”
With two outs, there's no guarantee you'll get another chance to score with the ball in play. That's when I want our runners forcing the defense to make a play.
“As a third base coach, you have much less pressure here -- play it loose (within reason)!”
A runner on first with two outs probably needs two hits to score, but a runner on second only needs one. I tend to recommend taking that risk early in the count.
“If you get thrown out, so what? With two outs, you're just much less likely to score from first base.”
I watched a coach pull two outfielders in the middle of an inning for playing at exactly the level they'd been trained to play. He embarrassed those players to make a point.
“Baseball is a game. It's not life or death. Stop treating it that way.”
Before you volunteer to coach your son's team, ask him whether he wants you to. Don't assume you know the answer -- being the coach's kid isn't always easy.
“If he doesn't want this, it's really a non-starter. You shouldn't coach him.”
I never sat a player two innings in a row. Two straight innings on the bench is long enough for him to lose track of the game, and when he goes back out, he's cold.
“If he has to sit twice, sit him in the second and the fifth, not the second and the third.”
Simple signs are critical to clear communication. A complicated system only makes it more likely that a player misses a sign and his coach gets mad at him for it.
“If they know, so what? You have to throw us out.”
These were the 11 players I committed to for a year, and their families committed to us. I'd much rather win -- or lose -- with them than with a couple of borrowed ringers.
“Benching players in favor of kids who have no skin in the game is a slap in the face.”
When a coach gets angry at his players' mistakes, it's usually because he's embarrassed. The rate at which they make those mistakes is a reflection of their training, and that's on us.
“They're doing what you taught them to do. Good and bad.”
Coaches who are afraid of being the screamer often swing the other way and praise everything. If you tell a player a bad swing was a good one, you're only reinforcing the habit.
“Okay. You're going to be okay. Turn the page. Deep breath. Nothing over your hands, right?”
I grew up on practices full of lines, and I ran practices like that for years. A good practice doesn't need to be long, but every drill needs a purpose and everyone needs to be moving.
“Every moment spent standing around is a moment wasted.”
Plenty of youth defenses try to get both runners on a first and third and end up with neither. Pick the runner who matters most based on the outs, the score and who's hitting -- then keep the other team guessing.
“The defense should be focused primarily on the runner at first or the runner at third -- not both.”
Most teams don't have a special arm, and that's okay. You can still win at the youth level with a pitcher who hits his spots, a catcher who works the batter and a defense that makes plays.
“No pitch is more difficult to hit than one that is low and away.”
Playing the infield in is a trade of risk for reward, and most coaches only count the reward. Know what a drawn-in infield gives away before you call for it.
“Drawing the infield in may save you a run, but it also makes a big inning more likely.”
The "bad-ball hitter" is largely a myth, at least at the youth level. Players remember the one bad pitch they crushed and forget about all of the outs.
“Your best hitters aren't passive. They simply need to be aggressive on the right pitches.”
I didn't manage league games, pool play and bracket play the same way. League games and Saturdays were where we spread out the reps, and Sundays were about giving us the best chance to keep playing.
“The more you win on Sunday, the more reps everyone gets.”
When we as coaches put the spotlight on ourselves, our priorities are out of order. The game belongs to the players, and our job is to guide them from the background.
“This isn't your show, man.”
When it's cold and rainy, I'll acknowledge it once before the game and never again. Both teams are playing in it, so I'd rather my players treat it as a challenge than an excuse.
“Yes, it's cold. We won't mention it again.”
When most coaches build a roster, they hunt for big bats and big arms. I'd take them too, but our 14u team was built on athletes who could play multiple positions.
“If you aren't developing good outfielders, you will pay for it later.”
I truly see four coaches as the limit for a youth team, and three is usually plenty. Put six coaches in the dugout of an 11-player team and you've got Daddy Ball on steroids.
“If you're only there to babysit your own kid, get out of the freaking dugout.”
If you're open to questioning it, you may see what I see: The defensive error is the most worthless, problematic stat in all of baseball. Stop using it.
“Tommy doesn't make mistakes. His range sucks.”
Most physical errors come from a lack of reps, and those are going to happen. A mental error usually comes from a lack of preparation -- and that's where I look at myself first.
“If we as coaches don't focus our disappointment productively, we can expect the same negative result to happen over and over again.”
Pitching decisions should be supported by the numbers, but only the right ones, in the right order. Strike percentage tells you far more about a youth pitcher than his ERA does.
“Stats tell everything and nothing at the same time.”
Dad coaches are so worried about looking like Daddy Ball that many of them overcorrect and come down hardest on their own son. The truth is that this is just as bad -- and it may even be worse.
“What if another coach treated your son this way? Would you stand for it?”
After the last game of the day, I'd give a gaudy, gold-looking chain to whoever was money that day. He took a knee, I put it around his neck, and he led the count-out.
“It screams LOOK AT ME, and that's intentional. We want people to notice it.”
Most youth scorekeepers are volunteer parents. Give them a guide that says how you want things scored, so three different parents scoring three different games still produce the same book.
“There are times when I don't want our scorekeepers going 'by the book.'”
We let our catchers call the game, but they always started from the same general approach. Everything else they did was an adjustment to the hitter, the pitcher and the situation.
“There's rarely a clear right or wrong call on any given pitch.”
Whenever there's a coin flip in pool play, it almost always makes the most sense to be the visitor. I've stood in hundreds of coaches meetings, and I can't remember another coach choosing it.
“When 99% of coaches choose to be the home team, you're going to win 99% of these flips.”
Down 21-5 in the final inning, we watched a runner walk off third and ask us to tag him. I know their hearts were in the right place, but that out was an invitation for us to quit.
“I don't want to cheapen our comeback. So feel free. Run up the score.”
Batting average tells you the least about who's really hitting. I'd rather look at OPS, on-base with errors counted, contact rate, line-drive rate and first-pitch swing rate.
“When I'm deciding who plays, I want rates instead of totals, and I want them from a scorekeeper I trust.”
Is he pulling everything foul? Late on the fastball? Crowding the plate? The batter tells you what to throw next, and a catcher who's watching will see it before anyone in the dugout does.
“If he can't catch up to the fastball, don't speed up his bat with a changeup.”
I value stats, but I also understand their limits. At the youth level, a small sample and a biased scorekeeper can make the numbers tell almost any story you want.
“We can't wait out a 30-50 at-bat slump in youth baseball. That's often a third of a season.”
League games, pool play and bracket play are three different kinds of games, and I'd treat them that way. Spread the reps out where you can afford to, and put your best lineup on the field on Sunday.
“Development happens in league games. Bracket play is about seeing how good you are.”
Whether you're safe or out comes down to two times: yours and the ball's. We timed everything at practice so our players could see it for themselves.
“We had more time than we thought. In some cases, we could go all the way to second and still make it back.”
Some of our best practices happened in a classroom, with nine magnets on a whiteboard. When players understand why they're standing somewhere, they don't need a coach yelling at them during the game.
“Grab the magnet for your position, and move it to where you need to be.”
Every player on a youth roster is there because you asked him to be. If you bury him on the bench, you're admitting that you made a mistake when you added him.
“Play them -- all of them.”
Each player writes down one strength, one weakness, three specific things he'll do about it, measurable team and personal goals and how he'll lead. Then the coach sits down with him to go over it, and again at midseason.
“It can't just be 'practice harder.' These need to be specific things you'll actually do.”
Baseball traditionalists treat ERA as the be-all-end-all. I look at strike percentage, first-pitch strikes and walks first to see who actually pitched well.
“Particularly at the youth level, allowing runs is heavily influenced by defense.”
You can't fix a player's footwork between pitches. I learned to make a note of it, let it go and save the coaching for practice.
“The coaches I respect most, I rarely hear.”
The most important spot in the lineup is often the bottom. If you put those batters on base, the chance for damage when the top of the order comes up is high.
“You must be more aggressive with these hitters. Make them hit the ball.”
Being on time means each player is on the field with his cleats on, ready to start warmups. If the coach doesn't spell that out, every family will define it for themselves.
“Every player beat me there, so I couldn't blame the traffic. I needed to plan better.”
Coaching asks you to be a teacher, a strategist, an organizer and a motivational speaker all at once. We aren't perfect, but these 13 traits describe the coach we want to be.
“I can tell you first hand that I'm not a motivational speaker.”
Treat your baseball cap as your Coach Cap. When you put it on in the dugout, you're Coach, and when you take it off after the game, you're Dad again.
“When we're on the field, my son calls me Coach, not Dad.”
Our coaches didn't call pitches, pickoffs or first-and-third plays. The players did, and getting them ready to do it took a ton of work.
“Often they'd call something different than I would, and it worked!”
I learned this the hard way: Overestimate every expense and budget for the smallest roster you might have, so the surprise at the end of the season is money back instead of a request for more.
“Asking for more money was one of my most difficult conversations of the season. It was the worst.”
When your own son tells you that you're talking to him as Dad instead of Coach, listen. I know how much that stings, because my son said it to me.
“That one cut deep, and it forced me to reassess how I was talking to him.”
With a runner on second, we'd show bunt just to see what the infield did. A well-coached team keeps third base covered, but a lot of teams leave it wide open.
“When a batter squares to bunt, it creates some initial chaos and panic.”
One coach thinks the line is 10 runs and another thinks it's 15. Most of the anger over running up the score comes from that ambiguity rather than bad intent, so if your league wants a rule, put it in writing.
“If your team is trailing and you haven't quit, why should the other team stop trying?”
I pulled three seasons of big-league results by count, then ran the numbers on our own 14u games. In both, the hitter who took a first-pitch strike paid for it.
“Once you take that first strike, you don't get back to the same odds until 2-1.”
A runner who hesitates kills his own momentum and leaves his coach unsure what to do. If he's already moving, the coach can always hold him up.
“Due to his hesitation, now I'm not so sure he should go -- but it's too late.”
Telling a player to keep his hands here and his hips there doesn't fix a swing he's had for years. A good drill teaches his body how to move without him knowing it.
“Simple reps won't help if they don't fix a problem. Only productive reps do.”
A signed contract gives the coach something to point to when a player or a parent isn't living up to expectations. In the worst case, it's also what protects him.
“Don't assume that just because you talked about your rules that everyone understands them.”
A smart hitter who's down 0-2 is sitting on the changeup, because that's what most youth pitchers throw there. Get comfortable enough with every pitch that the count doesn't decide what's coming.
“A batter shouldn't know an offspeed pitch is coming on 0-2 any more than he knows a fastball is coming on 2-0.”
Time limits in youth tournaments invite stalling, and the rules don't do much to stop it. I understand the temptation, but I don't do it, and it can backfire on you.
“Stalling says you don't think you can win the game by playing it.”
The traditional batting order gives your best hitters fewer plate appearances. I'd rather stack my best hitters at the top and let those extra trips to the plate add up over a season.
“I have no problem batting my most powerful hitter first. He'll come up with runners on anyway.”
At the youth level, a bunt wastes valuable strikes and gives away outs, usually to move a runner who could have moved up on his own.
“When a coach tries to give me an out, I thank him.”
If your team almost never loses, you aren't challenging your players enough. Move up a level, and keep moving up until you start losing regularly.
“You should not win every tournament.”
The goal of a pickoff move is to create uncertainty for the runner. If your pitcher varies the move and how long he holds the ball, the runner can't time him.
“It's not necessary that a pitcher ever picks a runner off at all.”
I didn't call pitches from the dugout. Our catchers called the game, because it's faster, it's harder to steal, and it creates a thinking baseball player instead of a robot.
“It's a beautiful thing when a catcher calls a great game and the coach can't take credit.”
Parents along the fence think the dad coach loves handing his son the ball with the game on the line. Most of them have no idea what's going through his head.
“I can't complain about the role my kid serves when I'm the coach.”
"Score more runs" is true, but it doesn't help a 10-year-old much. Winning comes from a long list of small things that he may not connect to the scoreboard until innings later.
“We will score more runs if you can't get us out.”
I very rarely gave a take sign, because I want my hitters to swing the bat. If you give one to a struggling hitter at 2-0, you're telling him you'd rather he walk.
“You're hoping for a walk because you expect him to get out.”
Coaches love to cry disloyalty when a family moves on. But that family made what they believe is the best choice for their son, and it isn't something you should take personally.
“Cries of disloyalty are a coach shifting the blame for losing players.”
Every stat a coach uses to make playing time decisions is only as good as the person entering it. Pick a scorekeeper who knows the game, has no agenda and pays attention on every pitch.
“For many of these stats to have value, the scorekeeper must be vigilant.”
I wanted to win every time we stepped on the field. But abusing arms, breaking rules, burying kids and hunting trophies is what winning at all costs looks like, and it's bad for youth baseball at every level.
“It starts with a coach whose ego is so fragile that he can't personally lose.”
I spent more than 15 years as a dad coach, and I wouldn't trade it for anything. But there are seven questions you should answer honestly before you volunteer…
“We need dad coaches (and mom coaches, too). The alternative just isn't realistic.”
I only used subs for two reasons: To avoid a forfeit or automatic outs, and as insurance at an out-of-state tournament. Adding them for a better shot at winning is where the trouble starts.
“If you add subs without truly needing them, play better as a result, and win the tournament, did you really deserve it?”