Fungo FilesNotes from a baseball coach
Fungo Files
For coaches

The traditional lineup is wrong for youth baseball

The call

The traditional batting order gives your best hitters fewer plate appearances. I'd rather stack my best hitters at the top and let those extra trips to the plate add up over a season.

You know the traditional lineup. The fastest kid leads off, a fast contact hitter bats second, your best hitter bats third and your power hitter bats cleanup. Then everyone else.

It’s tradition, and it’s also an outdated approach — particularly for youth baseball.

The order that tends to score the most runs looks nothing like that. It stacks your best hitters at the top of the order, so they get the most plate appearances. You may not notice the difference in one game, but over the course of a season, those extra at-bats turn into runs.

Here are the factors I look at instead…

On-base percentage, with a caveat. In youth ball, a player who never swings can draw a lot of walks against bad pitching, and he’ll hurt you against good pitching. He needs to do more than walk.

Batting average, because it rewards contact and speed.

Slugging. I have no issues whatsoever with putting my best power hitter in the leadoff spot. He loses a few RBI chances, but he gains plate appearances all season. And in youth ball, the bottom of the order gets on base often enough that your leadoff hitter won’t be hitting with the bases empty very often.

Strikeouts. A lot of strikeouts in youth ball usually means a hitter is overmatched by good pitching.

Speed, but NOT the way you think. Your fastest player isn’t your leadoff hitter if he can’t get on base. Speed is a tiebreaker between similar hitters. If three players hit about the same, the fastest one bats first, so the slower ones don’t clog up the bases in front of him.

How do you put your lineup together?

Still have a question? Ask Coach Fungo.

Coach Fungo says
“I have no problem batting my most powerful hitter first. He'll come up with runners on anyway.”
— Coach Fungo

I wrote the long version of this when I coached the Spiders: How to Assemble the Ultimate Youth Baseball Lineup on SpidersElite.

Want a few of these in your inbox?

I'll send you the seven tools right away, then one email a month with a few cards worth your time. You can stop any time with one tap.

Be the first to comment