Fungo FilesNotes from a baseball coach
Fungo Files
For coaches

Stop scoring defensive indifference in youth baseball

The call

If the first baseman held the runner on and the pitcher threw from the stretch, I score it a stolen base. The defense wasn't indifferent just because the catcher didn't throw.

I’m trying to do a public service here. In my opinion, defensive indifference gets scored FAR more often than it should in youth baseball. Let’s think about a common scenario…

There’s a runner on first, and the first baseman is holding him on while the pitcher works from the stretch. The runner gets a huge jump, and the catcher doesn’t bother to throw. The scorekeeper enters “defensive indifference.”

That is wrong.

By definition, defensive indifference is a late-game, lopsided situation where the defense makes no attempt to stop the runner. I hate that definition, because in youth baseball it’s almost never applied that way. It’s applied because the catcher didn’t make a throw.

But was the defense indifferent? The first baseman was holding the runner on, and the pitcher was in the stretch, so they clearly cared.

The runner beat them with a great jump, and he did exactly what a player is supposed to do.

My test is simple: Score defensive indifference only if the pitcher threw from the windup, or if the first baseman wasn’t holding the runner. If either of those is true, then fine (they didn’t care). Otherwise, it’s a stolen base.

The same goes for first-and-third plays where the throw gets cut off. Did the first baseman hold him on? Was the pitcher in the stretch? If so, it’s a steal. I’d rather not try to read minds about intent.

Don’t get cute, and don’t try to impress anyone with your knowledge of this thing called defensive indifference, because it barely exists at this level.

Just give that kid a stolen base. He deserves it.

Still have a question? Ask Coach Fungo.

Coach Fungo says
“Why would you rob a runner of a stolen base simply because he got a huge jump?”
— Coach Fungo

I wrote the long version of this when I coached the Spiders: Stolen Bases, Wild Pitches, Passed Balls, and Defensive Indifference on SpidersElite.

Want a few of these in your inbox?

I'll send you the seven tools right away, then one email a month with a few cards worth your time. You can stop any time with one tap.

Be the first to comment