When should you draw the infield in?
Playing the infield in is a trade of risk for reward, and most coaches only count the reward. Know what a drawn-in infield gives away before you call for it.
All baseball strategies are a balance of risk and reward. The problem is that most coaches don’t give nearly enough thought to the risks when going for that reward.
There’s no better example than the “infield in” strategy.
The concept is simple. There is at least a runner on third base with fewer than two outs. The coach calls the third baseman, shortstop, second baseman, and first baseman to all move closer to the plate, usually on the edge of the infield grass.
The goal is to prevent the runner on third from scoring on a ground ball. This could be accomplished by throwing the runner out at home. But it could also be that a ground ball hit directly to an infielder could prevent the runner on third from attempting to advance.
Of course, if there were no risk to this strategy, we’d draw the infield in on every play. But that’s obviously not the case.
When you draw the infield in, it severely limits an infielder’s range. If the ball isn’t hit directly to them, it’s more likely to find a hole and the outfield grass. That means that balls in play that would otherwise be turned to outs at first with the infield at normal depth become hits.
And that doesn’t only include ground balls. This also includes line drives, bloopers, and popups that get over the drawn-in infield. Batting average on balls in play improves significantly with the infield in.
But the full risk isn’t reflected in batting average. A drawn-in infielder may throw the ball home, but it doesn’t guarantee an out. Even if the runner at home is safe, it’s a fielder’s choice out for the batter in the box score. And the elimination of a forceout (unless the bases are loaded) leads to rushed throws and errors.
We’re not done documenting the risks. Consider a situation where there are runners on both second and third. In an effort to prevent the runner on third from scoring, you are increasing the likelihood of a base hit by drawing in the infield. And if that hit happens, the runner on second is likely to score, too.
And the final risk is that by increasing the likelihood the batter reaches safely on a ball in play, you are increasing the odds of a big inning. Particularly if the infield is drawn in with no outs. If the batter reaches base safely, he may score, too.
There’s a place and time for the drawn-in infield. But the one time that should leave no debate is when the winning run is on third with fewer than two outs. At any other time, you can argue that the risk of giving up more runs may not be worth the reward of trying to prevent a single run.
This includes when the tying run is on third in the top of the final inning. If you bat last, a tie isn’t the end of the world. And if you have runners on second and third with one out, drawing the infield in will make it more likely you’ll lose the lead.
The most blatant abuse of this strategy is early in a game. Unless you expect it to be a 2-1 or 1-0 final, which is impossible to know for sure, drawing the infield in can be a careless risk. It may just make it more likely you’ll lose that low-scoring game.
Don’t make these decisions based on gut. I’d document every time you have the infield in, and what happened as a result. How often do you execute? Know your team and the level when deciding whether the risk is worth the potential reward.
When the winning run is on third, bring the infield in. Any other time, understand that you may be trading one run for the potential of a big inning.
Still have a question? Ask Coach Fungo.
“Drawing the infield in may save you a run, but it also makes a big inning more likely.”
Win or lose with the players who got you here
These were the 11 players I committed to for a year, and their families committed to us. I'd much rather win -- or lose -- with them than with a couple of borrowed ringers.
“Benching players in favor of kids who have no skin in the game is a slap in the face.”
Budget your travel team so you give money back
I learned this the hard way: Overestimate every expense and budget for the smallest roster you might have, so the surprise at the end of the season is money back instead of a request for more.
“Asking for more money was one of my most difficult conversations of the season. It was the worst.”
The playbook
Thirty-three defensive plays, animated. Cutoffs, relays, first-and-third, bunt coverage.
New cards land on Instagram and Threads first. Follow along there.
Be the first to comment