Fungo FilesNotes from a baseball coach
Fungo Files
For coaches

Why I don’t call pitches

The call

I didn't call pitches from the dugout. Our catchers called the game, because it's faster, it's harder to steal, and it creates a thinking baseball player instead of a robot.

I didn’t call pitches from the dugout. If you watched one of our games, you may have noticed something different. The catcher wasn’t looking over at the dugout between pitches.

Most coaches call every pitch. The catcher looks over, the coach flashes signs, the catcher misses it and asks again, and then he relays it to the pitcher. Multiply that by about 120 pitches. It slows the game to a crawl, and seven fielders are standing around losing focus while it happens.

It’s also a game of Telephone. There are two handoffs instead of one (coach to catcher, then catcher to pitcher), so someone misses a sign, someone gets yelled at, and a pickoff throw sails into the outfield.

And the signs get stolen. To make them fast, coaches make them simple, and simple signs are readable from the stands. Next thing you know, someone on the other side is yelling, “Watch the offspeed!”

But the real reason is bigger than any of that.

This is their game, and I don’t want to create robots.

A catcher who takes signs isn’t thinking. A catcher who calls the game is thinking about the count, the hitter, the score and what worked last inning, on every pitch. When he gets to high school, he’s ready to be a leader whether the coach calls pitches or not.

It’s messy at first — ours was chaos at 11u. We taught it, we talked between innings and we let them fail, and by that fall, it had really started to click.

Start in league games or pool play, where it doesn’t matter as much. Give it a season, not an inning. You may be surprised.

Still have a question? Ask Coach Fungo.

Coach Fungo says
“It's a beautiful thing when a catcher calls a great game and the coach can't take credit.”
— Coach Fungo

I wrote the long version of this when I coached the Spiders: Coaches, Catchers, and Calling Pitches on SpidersElite.

Want a few of these in your inbox?

I'll send you the seven tools right away, then one email a month with a few cards worth your time. You can stop any time with one tap.

Be the first to comment