Fungo FilesNotes from a baseball coach
Fungo Files
For coaches

Stats lie, especially in youth baseball

The call

I value stats, but I also understand their limits. At the youth level, a small sample and a biased scorekeeper can make the numbers tell almost any story you want.

I’m an admitted stats nerd. I also know that stats can lie.

At the professional level there are controls in place, like experienced scorers, huge sample sizes and technology, and none of that exists at a youth field. Let’s look at a few of the ways the numbers get bent…

The scorekeeper. He’s usually a volunteer parent with some bias and some gaps in what he knows. Wild pitch or passed ball? Hit or fielder’s choice? Those calls change batting averages and ERAs — and they’re being made by somebody’s dad.

Subjective stats. The error is the worst of them. Ask three people whether he should have made that play, and you’ll get three answers. It’s why I ask my scorekeepers not to score errors on the opposition at all (if our player puts it in play and reaches, it’s a hit).

Quality of opponent. A coach is likely to save his ace for the best teams in the biggest games, while his fourth pitcher gets a weeknight league game. When their stats look similar, does that mean the fourth pitcher is just as good?

Sample size. A pro can slump for 50 at-bats and work his way out of it. In youth baseball, 50 at-bats is about 20 games. We’re forced to make lineup decisions on tiny samples, so we have to be willing to admit when we were wrong.

Recency. Players develop and change, so last month tells you a lot more than last year.

That’s why it’s important to value process over results, particularly in small samples. Is he swinging at good pitches? Is he hitting the ball hard? Those tell you where the numbers are going.

Still have a question? Ask Coach Fungo.

Coach Fungo says
“We can't wait out a 30-50 at-bat slump in youth baseball. That's often a third of a season.”
— Coach Fungo

I wrote the long version of this when I coached the Spiders: Stats Lie: Baseball Stats and the Stories They Tell on SpidersElite.

Want a few of these in your inbox?

I'll send you the seven tools right away, then one email a month with a few cards worth your time. You can stop any time with one tap.

Be the first to comment