If his arm is sore, he doesn’t pitch
When a pitcher told me his arm was sore, he didn't pitch, and there was no debate. The bigger job for a coach is not creating sore arms in the first place.
Unless it’s Little League (which has very good pitching rules), arms can get abused at the tournament level. Some tournaments have pitching limits, and plenty don’t. Even with limits, the damage can happen inside them.
I’ve seen a pitcher throw 40 pitches in one inning, or 100-plus at 11 years old, or pitch in two games on the same day. Then he says his arm is sore, and the coach sends him out there anyway.
As a coach, I actively encouraged my players to tell me how they felt. We did not mess with sore arms. You simply did not pitch. Soreness and injury aren’t the same thing, of course, but the line between them can be blurry — and I wasn’t going to be the one who found out where it was.
Why does this keep happening? Because coaches allow the overwhelming need to win the next game to control what they do.
If you truly care about these kids, you’re more concerned about them pitching next month and next year than winning that game right now.
Prevention is a big part of it. Watch pitches, not just innings. Pull a pitcher before he hits the limit, not when he gets there, and don’t throw your ace on Saturday and Sunday because the bracket got tight.
And a player who pitched on Sunday should get the week off from the mound.
Still have a question? Ask Coach Fungo.
“Yes, there's a difference between soreness and an injury, but the difference isn't always clear.”
I wrote the long version of this when I coached the Spiders: Winning at All Costs on SpidersElite.
Why I don’t call pitches
I didn't call pitches from the dugout. Our catchers called the game, because it's faster, it's harder to steal, and it creates a thinking baseball player instead of a robot.
“It's a beautiful thing when a catcher calls a great game and the coach can't take credit.”
Build your roster around defense, not big bats
When most coaches build a roster, they hunt for big bats and big arms. I'd take them too, but our 14u team was built on athletes who could play multiple positions.
“If you aren't developing good outfielders, you will pay for it later.”
The playbook
Thirty-three defensive plays, animated. Cutoffs, relays, first-and-third, bunt coverage.
New cards land on Instagram and Threads first. Follow along there.
Be the first to comment