Fungo FilesNotes from a baseball coach
Fungo Files
For coaches

Why ERA is the last pitching stat I look at

The call

Baseball traditionalists treat ERA as the be-all-end-all. I look at strike percentage, first-pitch strikes and walks first to see who actually pitched well.

Earned run average is the first pitching stat most people look at. It’s the last one on my list, and that’s on purpose.

I see allowing runs as more of a team stat. The pitcher contributes, of course — but so does the shortstop with no range, the first baseman who can’t scoop and the right fielder who took a bad angle. None of that shows up as an error, but all of it shows up in ERA.

Here are the numbers I look at instead, in order…

Strike percentage. I want at least 60%. A pitcher who throws only half strikes is going to work deep into counts, and the walks will follow.

First-pitch strike percentage. If you start with a strike, you own the at-bat. Start with a ball, and the hitter knows a fastball is probably coming.

Walks plus hit batters plus wild pitches, per inning. This is the wildness metric, and it catches the pitcher who hurts you three different ways.

Strikeouts minus walks. If a pitcher has eight strikeouts and six walks, he had a rough day, no matter what his ERA says.

On-base percentage against. Walks and hit batters are entirely on the pitcher, while hits are at least partly on the defense, so this number leans toward what he controls.

Then hard-hit percentage (if your scorekeeper is up to it). A pitcher who gives up rockets and gets outs anyway is about to stop getting outs.

Then, at the very bottom, ERA. It’s worth a look, but it’s never worth a decision.

Where does ERA fall on your list?

Still have a question? Ask Coach Fungo.

Coach Fungo says
“Particularly at the youth level, allowing runs is heavily influenced by defense.”
— Coach Fungo

I wrote the long version of this when I coached the Spiders: Youth Pitching Stats that Matter Most on SpidersElite.

Want a few of these in your inbox?

I'll send you the seven tools right away, then one email a month with a few cards worth your time. You can stop any time with one tap.

Be the first to comment