Fungo FilesNotes from a baseball coach
Fungo Files
For parents

Unearned runs are no reason to keep scoring errors

The call

ERA was never a good way to evaluate a youth pitcher. I'd much rather measure the things he can control, like strikes, weak contact and strikeouts versus walks.

Whenever I suggested that we stop scoring errors, the same objection showed up, and it almost always came from the parent of a pitcher: “But that kid made an error, and some of those runs were UNEARNED!”

I find this argument laughable.

Baseball is a team sport. A defensive mistake with two outs doesn’t mean the pitcher is no longer responsible for anything that happens next. He still has to get the next guy out.

If ERA is your only way to evaluate a youth pitcher, you’re missing the point. He can’t control where the ball is hit or whether someone fields it. He can control throwing strikes and getting weak contact. Stats built around those things (strike percentage, weak hit percentage, strikeouts versus walks) are FAR more valuable for predicting performance than earned runs.

Of course, everyone’s ERA goes up if you stop separating earned from unearned. But it was never a good stat for evaluating a player — it’s really a team number that happened to be recorded while he was on the mound.

And if you’re the parent standing behind the scorekeeper asking whether that run was earned, I’m sorry, but you’re part of the problem I’m describing. We don’t need to assign blame for that run. Your son’s ERA will be a little higher, and that’s okay. No high school coach is going to care.

Still have a question? Ask Coach Fungo.

Coach Fungo says
“No scout is looking at your 11-year-old's ERA. Let it go.”
— Coach Fungo

I wrote the long version of this when I coached the Spiders: Don't Use Errors to Measure Defensive Performance on SpidersElite.

Want a few of these in your inbox?

I'll send you the seven tools right away, then one email a month with a few cards worth your time. You can stop any time with one tap.

Be the first to comment