Tie goes to the runner: is that a rule?
There's no such thing as a tie, and no rulebook mentions one. The umpire decides which happened first, the tag or the foot, every single time.
“Tie goes to the runner” may be the most repeated rule in youth baseball that isn’t actually a rule. We’ve all heard it on a bang-bang play at first base.
The umpire calls the runner out, and the first base coach yells, “Tie goes to the runner, blue!” But there’s no such rule, and there wasn’t a tie.
You won’t find a tie rule in the pro book, in high school or in Little League. Umpires are trained that a tie doesn’t exist. The ball beat him or it didn’t — and the umpire’s job is to decide which one happened. “I couldn’t tell” isn’t an answer he’s allowed to give.
What the rulebook actually says is that the runner is out if the base is tagged before he touches it. The key word is BEFORE. If you want to be a lawyer about it, a true dead heat would mean the base wasn’t tagged before he got there, and he’d be safe. That’s the closest thing to “tie goes to the runner” that exists. Does that ever really happen? It’s a play I’ve never seen called.
The umpire calls what he saw, and he saw one thing first.
How does he decide? He watches the base and listens for the ball. The foot hits the bag, the ball hits the glove, and one of those came first. Good umpires get this right far more often than the guy yelling from the coach’s box (they’re standing still and looking at the right spot, after all).
So where did the myth come from? My best guess is kickball, or maybe a coach who didn’t want to argue with a nine-year-old. It’s been passed down like the hands and the bat, and it has the same amount of rulebook behind it, which is none.
When it’s close and it goes against you, you can ask the umpire what he saw. But you can’t tell him about a rule that isn’t in the book.
Which rulebook? Official Baseball Rules 5.09(a)(10) and 5.09(b)(6): the runner is out if he or the base is tagged before he touches it. The word is before. No rulebook, pro, NFHS or Little League, mentions a tie, and umpire training in all three says the same thing: it was one or the other, call it.
Bang-bang play at first. The foot and the ball look like they got there at the same time. What does the rulebook say?
Still have a question? Ask Coach Fungo.
“Umpires are trained that there is no such thing as a tie. He has to call it one way or the other.”
Does the pitcher have to come set before a pickoff?
The stop is required before a pitch, not before a throw to a base. From the stretch, he can lift his hands and throw to first without ever stopping, as long as he steps toward the base.
“If he steps toward first before he throws, a quick pickoff without a stop is legal.”
Is a bobble an error if the runner would’ve been safe?
If the runner would have been safe even on a clean play, it's a hit. It often looks like an error, but the fielder was usually rushing because he had little or no chance anyway.
“Look at first base before you write down an E.”
The rules quiz
Ten questions, two minutes. Would you have gotten the call right?
New cards land on Instagram and Threads first. Follow along there.
Be the first to comment